As a teacher, I owe everything to Mr. Weiss. Mr. Weiss was my English teacher from fifth grade to eighth grade. He was an old man, even then, and now he’s not with us anymore. Despite his age, he was an imposing figure, and his primary tool in the classroom was domination through fear. In fact, most of his students did their homework and participated in his lessons because they were terrified of him. He walked with a limp, and told us it was because he’d been on the deck of a battleship in World War II, when a bomb hit the deck beside him, failed to explode, bounced, and tore open his thigh. I believed it. Some few of us, myself included, actually did our work not out of fear, but because we were so desperate for one word of praise, or even a faint smile from under his bushy moustache, that we’d do anything to get it. Even homework.
I was quite the screw-up in High School, and in fact only remember two of my High School teachers: Ms. McKulskie (and I don’t remember how to spell her name) because she was HOT, and Mr. Storch, because he did three very funny things, and because he reminded me of Mr. Weiss.
One day I was sitting in Mr. Storch’s class, and I was daydreaming. He taught Astronomy (my High School was one of the few in the world with its own Planetarium and a full-fledged Zeiss projector) and the subject always left me dreaming of becoming a starship captain and flying to other planets, like on Star Trek. My eyes were everywhere except where they should have been, and they wandered up into the upper corner of the room above the blackboard, where they noticed a small sign. It read: “If you are looking up here, you are not paying attention.” I burst out laughing. The sign had really gotten me, nailed me, as I was most assuredly not paying attention. Classy, I thought. Years later, I put the same sign up in my classroom at IS 93 in New York, and week after week students would come to me and say, “Hey, Mr., you got me.”
On another occassion, I asked Mr. Storch if he had the time. He looked at his wrist, at his watch, and said, “Yes, Mr. Soffer, I do.” And then he walked away without telling me what time it was.
Another time, he walked past me while I was sitting on the floor in a hallway at school, doing nothing as was my habit back then. He looked down at me, shook his head, and said, “Mr. Soffer, a mind is a terrible thing to waste.”
Yeah, I don’t remember much about High School, and didn’t learn much there. But Mr. Storch’s disdain, which might as well have been coming from Mr. Weiss, was probably the factor that made me realize I was screwing things up, and allowed me to get my life back together, so I could actually get to University. And, not surprisingly, I know more about astronomy than any three normal people put together.
It was at University that I met Mr. Rutigliano. As a teacher, I’m probably more similar to Mr. Rutigliano than either Mr. Storch or Mr. Weiss as, like me, Rutigliano probably didn’t know much about much. But he knew how to get his students interested, and how to make his class fun, and I learned a lot from him. In fact, I went to Italy with him twice, and actually managed to get credits towards graduation for sitting in fabulous gardens in Siena, drinking wine, and talking about not much of anything. Siena is my second favorite city in the world, right after Hanoi. In the future, maybe I’ll blog about Siena. It’s a medieval city, lost in time, oblivious to the way the world has changed in the last thousand years.
The other teacher at University that I remember was George Sideris. He was younger than Mr. Storch or Mr. Weiss, but on his way to becoming them. He taught science, and did it mostly through slides – photographs he’d taken himself and/or stolen from somewhere, that showed the most interesting things about the natural world from the most creative angles. When George taught me astronomy, I let him see everything Mr. Storch had burned into my brain, and George ended up thinking I was a pretty smart kid. I took a trip with George (we didn’t call him Mr. Sideris) to Georgia and Florida for a course called, “The Ecology of Sub-Tropical America – Fieldwork” or something like that. A lot of nights spent in sweaty swamps, trying to learn how to identify different kinds of birds. It was a week out of time, where I saw the most beautiful parts of America, sat on the most amazing beaches, and watched sunsets I will never forget. I even rowed a canoe past a hungry looking crocodile. Or maybe it was an alligator. Sorry, George.
From traditional to modern then, they were Mr. Weiss, Mr. Storch, Mr. Rutigliano, and George. They had something similar running through them, some vein that, as a teacher, I try to tap into.
At any rate, Mr. Weiss’s methods were harsh and old-fashioned. He taught a lot of grammar, gave a lot of homework, and he made us write. A lot. In fact, any writing ability I may have, I owe to Mr. Weiss. What I hated most was memorizing poetry. He’d give us a poem, make us memorize it, and then make us stand up in front of the class and do theatrical presentations of the poem. One of the poems, “The Snowman’s Resolution” by Aileen Fisher, I still remember word-for-word in its entirety to this day, for some reason.
When I became a teacher, I met another incarnation of Mr. Weiss in Mr. Moreno, one of the senior English teachers at the school were I worked my rookie years. Mr. Moreno was my mentor (all new teachers in New York get a mentor to help them over the rough spots). Sadly, he didn’t have much time for mentoring me. The school had recently changed over to some very modern teaching methodologies which I hated because they were different from Mr. Weiss’s methods and Mr. Moreno hated because they were different from his methods. Still, I was new and eager to please and so I dove into those new methods and tried to learn them. Moreno’s reaction was to say that I seemed to have a good handle on all that new fangled garbage, and thus had little need of him. It wasn’t true. I wish I could have said, “Look, man, you remind me of my hero, Mr. Weiss, and I want to learn everything you have to teach me, even if this crazy school won’t really let me use it.” But I never said that. Instead, I left Mr. Moreno in a dusty room filled with ill-used grammar books and spent most of my time in the world of teaching through “real literature.”
Mr. Weiss, Mr. Storch, and Mr. Moreno were all cut from the same cloth. They were also all over fifty when I met them. (Gee, Mr. Storch, you looked over fifty – I hope you were.) I’m not yet over fifty, and maybe that’s why I haven’t become them yet. I’m still trying to make my students “like” me, which is something neither of those three educators gave a good god-damn about. Of course, in the worlds of those three teachers, they had all the power. The students had to be there, had to pass if they wanted a future, and thus had to endure some pretty harsh and often unfriendly-seeming treatment.
In contrast, my students here in Hanoi pay to study with me, and that makes them customers. Customers and prisoners are too different things, and more often that not it seems that having them “like” me is more important to their signing up again then actually teaching them anything. Still, I do my best to “force” my students to learn, while at the same time being friendly and entertaining. It’s a painful irony that if I changed my methods into something more “Weissian” I’d at once do a better job teaching them and at the same time see them running for the hills.
What then is that vein that these most memorable teachers tapped into? It has something to do with authority, something to do with honesty, something do with a total absence of ego (let me repeat again that none of these teachers gave a damn what their students thought of them), something to do with knowledge, and something to do with love. Maybe the last element there is the most important. They didn’t love their students – that’s not the issue. They loved teaching. You felt it, because their lessons were always well prepared, their syllabi well organized, their lectures never boring, their assignments never busy-work. They were experts in their fields, and that meant that if you weren’t lazy, they could pass on some of that expertise to you.
What has me thinking about all of this is Thanh. Yesterday, she spent a moment after class to give me some websites where I could download the software to put a Vietnamese-English dictionary into my O2. It was nice of her to do that, and I felt kind of touched. It left me wondering if Thanh was fond of me, or just being nice. And if she is fond of me, then why? Because I’m doing a good job teaching her, or because I wiggle my ears, smile a lot, and do goofy things?
In the final analysis, I think we forget the teachers who become our “friends” very quickly. It’s the ones who force us to actually learn something that we never forget, that we, in fact, remember for as long as we carry the knowledge they gave us. If you’d met me in seventh grade and asked me what I thought of Mr. Weiss I would’ve said, “He’s old, ugly, has bad breath, and I hate his guts.” Now, all these years later, I remember him with such fondness he might as well have been my father.
Right now, there are a lot of Vietnamese students of English who will probably tell you, “Craig? Yeah, he’s really funny. He’s nice. I love his class.” But maybe in the future there will be other Vietnamese students who say, “Craig? He’s old, ugly, has bad breath, and I hated his guts when I was his student. But you know what? He sure did teach me a lot of English.”
If it happens that way, I’ll take it. In the long run, being someone’s Mr. Weiss is a lot more rewarding than just being “funny.” Hmm, after all this rambling, I’m probably going to give a lot of homework tonight, smile a lot less in class, and really hammer you if it seems you still “don’t get it.” If I do, forgive me. I’m just trying to be more like my sources of inspiration.